Page 1 of 1

Seeing the wrong words

Posted: Wed Oct 20, 2010 11:33 am
by Hunter
Every so often when I am reading something I read the wrong word or see another word, completely changing the meaning of the sentence. I usually pick up on it if I look at it again, and when I do, I think - What the f### just happened to my brain? It happens regardless of what it is, though if it's something I have little interest in then it's more frequent. It's not restricted to one language either, it happens whenever I read anything in Korean or Japanese too. It's annoying, because it can change the entire meaning of a sentence if you change one of the words around in your mind. I find it happens when I am listening to long-winded sentences too.

Anyone else experience this phenomenon? Am I dyslexic? Because I have always had this suspicion I am, if ever so slightly.. Or is this a side effect of becoming multi-lingual?

Re: Seeing the wrong words

Posted: Wed Oct 20, 2010 2:10 pm
by aldo
Hunter wrote:Every so often when I am reading something I read the wrong word or see another word, completely changing the meaning of the sentence. I usually pick up on it if I look at it again, and when I do, I think - What the f### just happened to my brain? It happens regardless of what it is, though if it's something I have little interest in then it's more frequent. It's not restricted to one language either, it happens whenever I read anything in Korean or Japanese too. It's annoying, because it can change the entire meaning of a sentence if you change one of the words around in your mind. I find it happens when I am listening to long-winded sentences too.

Anyone else experience this phenomenon? Am I dyslexic? Because I have always had this suspicion I am, if ever so slightly.. Or is this a side effect of becoming multi-lingual?
I have the same thing (english only, as non multi-lingual).

I would guess that it's down to something simple like pattern-recognition* mixed with some subconscious filtering... two layers of competing pre-processing. In that case it'd be expected to be more frequent if you are less interested in something.


*after all, the brain is IIRC more or less a giant pattern-recognition device

Posted: Wed Oct 20, 2010 3:38 pm
by Hunter
The odd thing is it happens when I am typing too. I sometimes have 'word typos' where I type a completely out of place word in a sentence.

Posted: Wed Oct 20, 2010 3:44 pm
by aldo
Hunter wrote:The odd thing is it happens when I am typing too. I sometimes have 'word typos' where I type a completely out of place word in a sentence.
Same principle, innit?

I think - an there's no scientific basis I've looked at for this, it's just an intuition - that there's a degree of parallelism going on. You have several active threads of thinking going on, which sometimes interact... sometimes one of those threads, say a subconscious sentence/phrase formation, overlaps with a conscious one directing keys to fingers (or translating read symbols into comprehended words), and the result gets slightly mixed.

I dunno if it's just me, but it's a bit like when I'm writing ACCIDENTALLY IN ALL-CAPS (*cough*) or something, and feel obliged to apologise inline rather than just delete it - like the brain overlaps your speaking action (in terms of vocalising words in your head as you read them) with your visual typing action or something.

Posted: Wed Oct 20, 2010 6:08 pm
by kosh
It happens on and off, usually when I'm reading something in english.

Posted: Wed Oct 20, 2010 9:32 pm
by Top Gun
I know one thing that happens to me quite frequently is that I'll be speaking or typing while doing something else, like watching TV or listening to a conversation or reading, and I'll mistakenly interject a word I just heard/read into what I'm saying. It happens almost completely subconsciously, too; the word will just pop out without even thinking about it. I don't know how much that applies to what you're describing, though.

Posted: Thu Oct 21, 2010 12:15 am
by ngtm1r
It's your brain trying to multitask and failing. I do it reasonably commonly when I write; working one plot thread, another intrudes on what I'm thinking, you end up with sentence that's half one and half the other.

Posted: Thu Oct 21, 2010 7:26 pm
by General Battuta
This happens to me while writing but never while reading. Interesting.

I think reading, like most complex mental activities, is partly predictive - you don't actually read everything on a 1:1 basis, you throw in what you expect and interpolate. Maybe your system is too enthusiastic.

Posted: Thu Oct 21, 2010 8:15 pm
by Snail
Happens to me sometimes too, but usually only when I'm not 100% engaged in reading.

Posted: Thu Oct 21, 2010 11:36 pm
by Matthew
Happens to me too, usually in chat rooms. Someone types one thing, I read something totally different.