Sectorgame

I have. I have seen Star Trek lines even in news reports.

I hear people say "damn it, Jim, I'm a doctor not a ____" all the time. But I've never heard anyone quote SG-1. :/

BloodEagle wrote:I hear people say "damn it, Jim, I'm a doctor not a ____" all the time. But I've never heard anyone quote SG-1. :/

That's pretty much the whole point. Putting relative merits aside, SG-1 couldn't even dream of achieving the complete cultural pervasiveness that Star Trek's 40+ years, or Star Wars's 30+, have managed. Even people who have never seen the series/movies in question are able to spout off lines and characters from them.

Well, Stargate and other new series aren't really the kind of light-hearted, humorous show that would produce a memorable quote that's both distinctive and used repeatedly. At least I have yet to notice one...

"Well, that went well."

"Ya think?"

"Remember that time when you blew up a sun?"

More to the point, if I walk up to somebody on the street and say "Spock" I probably have a chance higher than 75% they'll know who the f### that is.

If I say "Teal'c" I'd be damn lucky for a 50%.

I'd say 5%.

Matthew wrote:I have yet to hear those phrases in a typical "Casual" conversation.

I've never, but it's certainly still a good point.

But I don't think the lunatic fringe in their lycra costumes count.

''Impudence!!''

No, tuna...

ngtm1r wrote:

aldo wrote:But until that, yeah, Star Trek was pretty much an irrelevance except to the lycra costume wearing die-hard loonies.

Of course, the mere existence of such people proves it has reached a level of cultural penetration Stargate can only dream about.

On the other hand Star Trek has been around since the late 60's, part of it is just because of age.

Stargate has done well - It has 15 seasons, four movies (including the original and the one in production) and a third series is on the way.

kosh wrote:

ngtm1r wrote:

aldo wrote:But until that, yeah, Star Trek was pretty much an irrelevance except to the lycra costume wearing die-hard loonies.

Of course, the mere existence of such people proves it has reached a level of cultural penetration Stargate can only dream about.

On the other hand Star Trek has been around since the late 60's, part of it is just because of age.

On the other other hand (wait, who are we talking to here? Shiva? ), not many people could quote bits of - for example - Lost in Space, which is even older. So it can't just be age - age makes it more likely to be forgotten, surely?

Because lost in space died young and except that crappy remake was never revived. Star trek has 5 TV series and 11 theaterical movies, not the straight to dvd movies that stargate comes out with. Like I said, age is only part of the reason.

four movies (including the original and the one in production)

How many of those movies were released in theaters? From what I heard about trek movies 2-6, they were smash hits when released in the theaters, complete with people lining up around the block to see them.

I have to admit, I'm getting slightly confused - what are we actually discussing here?